A ROYAL DISPUTE, A PARTY DIVIDE AND A GOVERNMENT IN LIMBO

 



When the palace becomes part of the political equation, the real question is no longer who wants to become Menteri Besar. It is who is fighting whom, and what exactly are they fighting for?

I have read Tajuddin Rasdi's opinion piece in Free Malaysia Today, published on 19 November 2026. There is one observation worth examining: what initially appeared to be a confrontation between UMNO and the Negri Sembilan Palace has increasingly become an internal struggle within UMNO itself.



But I would take the question one step further.

Who is the struggle actually against? The Palace? The sitting Menteri Besar? UMNO's own state leadership? Or the political machinery that wants to decide who occupies the highest office in the state?

Let's separate the facts from the political theatre.


Understand how this mess began

This is not simply a disagreement over who should become Menteri Besar.

The Negri Sembilan crisis has deeper roots in the state's royal institution and its unique system of traditional leadership.

On 19 April 2026, a proclamation was issued by four individuals claiming to be the legitimate Undang, seeking to remove Tuanku Muhriz Tuanku Munawir as Yang di-Pertuan Besar and recognise Tunku Nadzaruddin Tuanku Ja'afar as his successor.

However, on 17 September 2026, the Attorney-General's Chambers (AGC) stated that the proclamation was invalid because it did not comply with Article 10 of the Negeri Sembilan Constitution 1959. The AGC also made an important clarification: the Menteri Besar and State Executive Council have no unilateral authority to remove the Yang di-Pertuan Besar.

That is a significant constitutional fact.

It means the dispute was never just a political disagreement between two camps. It involved the constitutional authority of the state's royal institution, the traditional authority of the Undang, and the limits of executive power.

Then came the political consequences.

Ismail Lasim, who became Menteri Besar on 2 August 2026, had previously endorsed the position taken by his Exco concerning Tuanku Muhriz. He subsequently confirmed that he had written to the Malay Rulers, but on 14 November announced the withdrawal of that earlier position, reaffirming the existing royal status quo.

In other words, the political ground shifted.


Who is fighting whom?

Let's identify the principal players, without confusing allegations, political positions and established facts.


Tuanku Muhriz Tuanku Munawir

Yang di-Pertuan Besar of Negeri Sembilan. His position became the centre of the April proclamation dispute. The AGC subsequently said the purported removal did not satisfy the constitutional requirements.


Datuk Ismail Lasim

Juasseh assemblyman and sitting Menteri Besar. He had endorsed the controversial Exco position, later withdrew his earlier letter to the Malay Rulers, and subsequently became the subject of a disputed resignation announcement.


Datuk Seri Ahmad Zahid Hamidi

UMNO president and BN chairman. He said Ismail resigned voluntarily and confirmed that UMNO had submitted one candidate to the Palace for the Menteri Besar position.


The ten former State Executive Councillors

They were involved in the earlier dispute concerning the ruler's position. Their Exco appointments were revoked by Tuanku Muhriz in September, and they later withdrew their court action.


There are two distinct struggles here:

The first is institutional: the constitutional authority of the Yang di-Pertuan Besar, the traditional institutions and the state executive.

The second is political: the position of Ismail Lasim, UMNO's choice of a successor, and the party leadership's role in determining who should lead the state government.

These struggles overlap, but they are not necessarily the same battle.


The resignation that created another problem

Now, this is where things become particularly interesting.

On 16 November, BN secretary-general Zambry Abdul Kadir announced that Ismail had resigned. Zahid subsequently said that the resignation was voluntary and that UMNO had submitted one name as a possible successor.

But the Palace issued a clarification on 17 November.

The royal household said the resignation letter had been delivered to Istana Hinggap at 12.16am by an individual identifying himself as Hamidi from a law firm. The Palace had yet to verify the letter's authenticity.

More importantly, it clarified that under the Negeri Sembilan Constitution, the Menteri Besar's resignation only takes effect with the Yang di-Pertuan Besar's consent.

Then, on 18 November, Ismail was granted an audience with Tuanku Muhriz. According to reports, the ruler instructed him to continue performing his duties as Menteri Besar.

The State Secretary also confirmed that his office had not received any official resignation notification from Ismail.

And on 19 November, Zahid maintained that BN had submitted one candidate, while Ismail continued carrying out official duties.

So, here is the obvious question:

If the incumbent is still performing his duties under the ruler's instruction, what exactly is the political urgency behind proposing a replacement before the resignation issue has been resolved?

That question deserves an answer.


So, who is the struggle actually against?

My reading is that there are three layers to this contest.


First: the struggle over constitutional authority.

The original dispute challenged the position of Tuanku Muhriz. The AGC's intervention was significant because it clarified that the Menteri Besar and Exco could not simply declare the ruler's position vacant.

This is not a matter of political preference. It is a matter of constitutional procedure.



Second: the struggle over political leadership within UMNO.

This is where Tajuddin Rasdi's observation becomes particularly relevant.

Zahid has acknowledged submitting one candidate for the Menteri Besar position. Ismail, meanwhile, remains in office pending the Palace's decision on his resignation.

The question is no longer merely whether UMNO wants a new Menteri Besar. It is also about how the party manages its relationship with an incumbent who has already been instructed to continue his duties.

UMNO has the right to manage its political nominations and internal affairs. But political nominations and constitutional appointments are two different things.

A party can propose. The constitutional process must still be respected.


Third: the struggle over public confidence.

Who is thinking about the people of Negri Sembilan while all this is happening?

The state needs a functioning Exco, a government capable of making decisions, and an administration that can concentrate on development, investment, public services and the cost of living.

Political uncertainty has an administrative cost. The rakyat should not become spectators paying for a show they never bought tickets for.



In Negri Sembilan, however, the "elephants" appear to have invited the palace, the political establishment and the constitutional machinery into the same room. And somehow, the furniture is still moving.

I would be careful about accepting the narrative that this is simply UMNO versus the Palace. The facts suggest a much more complicated situation.

Ismail was involved in the earlier royal controversy. He subsequently withdrew his position and reaffirmed Tuanku Muhriz's status. Now his own resignation has become another point of contention.

Zahid says a successor has been proposed. The Palace says the resignation must receive royal consent. Ismail has been instructed to continue serving.

Three different developments. One very complicated political equation.

And here is where I would challenge the political leadership: if the intention is genuinely to restore stability, why allow the process to generate even more uncertainty?

There is a difference between resolving a crisis and rearranging the chairs while the building is still shaking.

I am not suggesting that Zahid has no constitutional or political grounds to propose a replacement. Nor should Ismail's position be treated as untouchable. Both deserve to be examined through the proper constitutional process.

But political authority is not a blank cheque. Neither is a political announcement equivalent to a constitutional decision.

Better to get the process right than to rush into another chapter of confusion.

The struggle has moved from a royal-institutional dispute into a political contest over the leadership of Negeri Sembilan, particularly within UMNO's own political machinery.


But the "two dimensions remain connected."

Question

What the facts establish

Is Tuanku Muhriz still the ruler?

The AGC rejected the April removal proclamation.

Has Ismail resigned effectively?

His resignation was not yet confirmed by royal consent as of 19 November.

Has UMNO proposed a replacement?

Yes. Zahid confirmed one name was submitted.

Is Ismail still serving?

Yes, following the reported instruction from the ruler.

Is the political crisis resolved?

No.


The real test is not who gets to sit in the Menteri Besar's chair. It is whether everyone involved understands that the chair belongs to an office governed by constitutional rules, not personal ambition or party convenience.

If UMNO wants a different Menteri Besar, there is a constitutional way to pursue that objective. If Ismail wants to continue, his position must also be determined through the proper process.

And if the Palace has already given an instruction, political actors should be careful not to create a competing reality through press statements.

The rakyat did not elect a government to watch an endless succession of political episodes. They elected representatives to govern.

If the original battle was about the authority of the royal institution, and the latest battle is about who gets to become Menteri Besar, at what point does somebody finally put Negeri Sembilan and its people ahead of the political chessboard?

Comments